A Proposal for Peace in the Middle East

Interim Agreement on Joint Security and Humanitarian Procedures 

  The State of Israel and the Palestinian Authority, the representative of the Palestinian people,  (hereinafter the “Parties”),     

R e c o g n i z i n g both parties' desire for a secure, prosperous West Bank and State of Israel,   

A f f i r m i n g​ the mutual security interests of the parties involved,   

E x p r e s s i n g​ the hope for sustainable future negotiations,   

R e a l i z i n g​ the earnest desires of the United States and international community,   

E m p h a s i z i n g​ the goals and principles outlined in United Nations Resolutions 194, 242, and 338,    

V i e w i n g w i t h h o p e the potential for an agreement to kick-start the broader peace process,        

1. Article 1: Security Protocols  

a. Establishes a Joint Task Force (hereinafter “the JTF”) for conducting joint  security patrols—with the advice and support of the United States—between  Israeli and the Palestinian Authority personnel within the West Bank; 

i. Mandates that the task force exclusively undertake counter-terrorism  and security operations; 

1. Affirms that counter-terror operations be directed toward  containing Iranian and foreign threats to the State of Israel, the  United States, and the Palestinian Authority's regional partners; 

ii. Integrates Israel Defense Forces counter-terrorism operations within the  West Bank under the JTF command structure; 

iii. Designates the United States as coordinator and guarantor of joint  security patrols, facilitating training, equipment, and military-military  communication between IDF, PA, and international chains of command; 

1. Enables U.S. non-combat advisors to be embedded with JTF  command, with special oversight for a jointly-developed Rules of  Engagement; 

2. Directs the United States to initiate a training period for units  under JTF command for eighteen months; 

3. Outlines a ten-year period wherein the JTF may undertake joint  patrols through Area A, Area B, and Area C, in addition to  PA-operated patrols in Areas A, B, and C;  

4. Establishes, parallel with the ten-year patrol period, a phased  programme for the provision of military aid to Palestinian elements in the JTF, beginning with small arms and infantry  equipment, and progressing to up-armored vehicles and indirect  fire gun systems; 

5. Specifies that the United States Government, Israeli Government,  and Palestinian Authority fund the organization with the  respective states’ fiscal obligations subject to review after  meaningful increases in PA tax collection;  

b. Designates a one-year timeline for interim measures to streamline checkpoint  procedures within the West Bank; 

i. Retains thirty-five permanently-staffed checkpoints attached to the  Israeli barrier wall; 

ii. Eliminates twenty-six permanently-staffed checkpoints located along  transit lines within Area C; 

iii. Mandates the phased retirement of partially-staffed checkpoints within  the West Bank; 

iv. Designates a Joint Ombudsperson for Checkpoint Procedures  (hereinafter the “Joint Office”), with the aim of monitoring and  reviewing concerns relating to checkpoints in and bordering on the West  Bank; 

1. Tasks the Joint Office with collecting complaints, coordinating  the placement of observers at staffed checkpoints, and reviewing  the efficiency and equity of checkpoint procedures; 

2. Mandates that the Joint Office develop yearly reports reviewing  the progress of checkpoint reforms and ongoing challenges  regarding checkpoint procedures; 

3. Specifies that the Joint Ombudsperson be appointed with the  assent of the Government of Israel and Palestinian Authority,  where all UN member states are vested with nominating powers  to the position; 

4. Demands a three-year term of service for the Joint  Ombudsperson and their deputy; 

v. Directs a reduction in frequency of randomized search procedures at  checkpoints;  vi. Increases checkpoint throughput at border regions, with investments  from the United States to speed checkpoint proceedings; 

1. Encourages throughput improvements on checkpoints to be  focused on areas bordering East Jerusalem and Bethlehem; 

c. At the advice and consent of the United Nations General Assembly, establishes  Area B contiguity along roadways in the West Bank; 

i. Maintains Israeli Area B prerogatives on roadway security; 

d. Streamlines visa processes, with the aim of reducing processing delays, for  protected categories of West Bank and East Jerusalem residents, including: 

i. West Bank and East Jerusalem residents seeking visas to pursue  extended study in the State of Israel; 

ii. West Bank and East Jerusalem residents seeking visas for medical  procedures and visitation in the State of Israel; 

e. Begins the funding of the SPEDP development package that shall replace  UNRWA and resumes U.S. humanitarian and security aid, as articulated in  Annex B;   

2. Article 2: Territorial Stabilization 

a. Resolves to undertake procedures clarifying the territorial sovereignty of the  Government of Israel and Palestinian Authority in the West Bank, based on the  general principles outlined in UNSC Resolution 242 and 338, with reciprocal  modifications on a 1:1 basis (hereinafter “The Reciprocal Agreement”)  encompassing 4.31 percent of Palestinian territory; 

i. Establishes a Joint Technical Border Commission (hereinafter the  “JTBC”) composed of both Parties to conduct a technical demarcation of  the border no later than nine months from the date of the entry into  force of the Reciprocal Agreement, based on the Agreement’s general  principles; 

ii. Directs, as original intent and principle of the Reciprocal Agreement,  that the JTBC encompass the settlements of Ma'ale Adumim, Modiin  Illit, Ariel, North Ariel, Beitar Ilit, Southern East Bloc, Southern West  Bloc, Kfar Adumim, Gush Etzion, Kedumim, and Givat Ze'ev for  incorporation into the State of Israel, in exchange for the inclusion of  territory comprising of and adjacent to the Northern and Southern  Triangle Communities, including Umm-Al Fahm, Tayibe, Jatt and Baqa  Al-Gharbiyye and others so as to maintain equality in territorial transfer; 

iii. Shifts the planned Israeli barrier wall between the Northern Ariel  settlement bloc and Ariel settlement bloc westward, so as to maintain  Palestinian territorial contiguity without internal barriers to trade and  investment; 

iv. Directs the evacuation and dismantlement of Israeli settlements not  adjacent to the Green Line nor encompassed in the Reciprocal  Arrangement, (Masua, Yafit, Petzael, Argaman, Tomer, Gilgal, Netiv  Ha’Gedud, Niran, Yitav, Naama, Beita Haarva, Beit Cholga, Almong,  Kalia, Mitzpe Shalem, Ovnat, Vered Yericho, Hamra, Bekaot);  

v. Designates the JTF as the responsible party for border procedures at the  Allenby/King Hussein Bridge Border Crossing, with provision for the  phased translation of roles to the relevant sovereign parties; 

b. Implements a one-year freeze on Israeli settlement construction or enlargement  within the West Bank, subject to yearly renewal pending the implementation of  the Reciprocal Agreement; 

i. Affirms the reversal of barrier wall construction within East Jerusalem; 

c. Suggests that housing incentives be furnished for Israeli citizens permanently  relocating from West Bank settlements to the State of Israel; 

i. Outlines a joint evacuation procedure for former Israeli settlers, with  options to return to the State of Israel or remain as Israeli citizens who  are permanent residents of Palestine; 

ii. Specifies the legal and fiscal obligations of former settlers selected for  integration into Palestine, such that they are entitled to basic political  representation in municipal affairs commensurate with their fiscal  contributions; 

d. Guarantees, pursuant to the obligations implied in any territorial swap  procedure, that Arab Israeli citizens located in the territories transferred to  Palestine may choose to retain their citizenship status, especially with respect to  the transit and political rights this status entails;  

i. Mandates legal limitations to municipal admissions committee policies  and housing regulations directed at Palestinian citizens of the State of  Israel; 

e. Designates the United States and, pending their invitation, the Arab League and  European Union as guarantors of the Reciprocal Agreement’s entry into force  and subsequent implementation; 

f. Clarifies the need for continued negotiation over the final status of Palestinian  territory in Gaza and both states’ respective obligations on the matter;   

3. Article 3: Humanitarian Protocols 

a. Directs talks within five years to discuss the reduction of tariffs, quotas, and  other barriers to trade, labor, and capital flows;  

b. Mandates a five-year transition of tax collection duties within the West Bank  from the Israeli Ministry of Finance to the PA Treasury Department, with the  oversight and support of the United States; 

c. Guarantees the extension of legal due process to the Parties’ citizens in their  respective custodies; 

i. Resolves that the respective Ministries of Justice shall formally notify  their counterparts within twelve hours of arrest; 

ii. Prohibits the arrest of citizens by both Parties without formal charges  filed within twenty-four hours of arrest; 

d. Suspends the Joint Water Committee approvals process for UN-approved water  projects within the West Bank within three years; 

i. Demands increased meeting frequency of the Joint Water Committee,  with bimonthly meetings necessary so long as backlogs of one hundred  or greater projects remain; 

ii. Mandates a five-year timeframe for improving water infrastructure, with  special emphasis placed on replacing inefficient and leaky water  systems, transferring water development prerogatives within the West Bank to the Palestinian Authority, and guaranteeing continued water  supplies for former settlers with Palestinian resident status; 

e. Streamlines the work permit awards process for skilled and unskilled  Palestinian laborers commuting to Israel; 

i. Calls for Israel to increase the number of work permits extended to  Palestinian workers; 

ii. Proposes established cooperation between the PA and Israel to oversee  the permit extension process and to cooperate on security checks on  permit applicants. 

 4. Article 4: Interim Agreement on Jerusalem and Holy Sites 

a. Recognizes the City of Jerusalem as centrally important to Jewish, Christian, and  Muslim faiths, and commits to preserving its fundamental character and  religious significance; 

i. Declares that the Jewish and Armenian quarters of the Old City be  maintained under Israeli sovereign authority, while the Muslim and  Christian quarters remain under Palestinian sovereignty;  

ii. Ensures free movement of peoples within the Old City, subject to  regulations ensuring hygiene and decorum at religious sites;  

1. Specifies that entry and exit points of the Old City be secured by  the Parties whose borders abut their location;  

b. Establishes, in recognition of its historical and religious significance to all faiths,  a secure transitional agreement for security over the Haram al-Sharif/Temple  Mount complex (hereinafter “the Complex”) to preserve its sanctity for the  international community;  

i. Reaffirms present Hashemite custodianship over the Muslim and  Christian Holy Sites in East Jerusalem pursuant to Article 9 of the 1994  Treaty of Peace Between the State of Israel and the Hashemite Kingdom  of Jordan and the March 2013 Agreement between Jordan and the  Palestinian Authority; 

ii. Empowers a Custodianship Council comprised of Palestine, Israel, the  United States, and, with successful invitation, Jordan; 

1. Affirms the Council’s role as a steering committee for disputes  concerning the Complex, and to perform security and  conservation duties in the interim period;  

2. Declares the Council’s mandate to employ JTF elements for  maintaining day-to-day security over the Complex in the interim  period; 

3. Emphasizes, consistent with past practice and in light of the  security considerations and religious decorum determined by the  Waqf, that visitors be permitted to access the site without  discrimination, including but not limited to race, religion, sex, gender/gender expression, sexual orientation, physical ability,  place of origin, age, and nationality;  

4. Declares that the United States and Jordan’s involvement will be  phased out pursuant to the timeline of the greater JTF mandate;  

iii. Directs, in view of its spiritual significance, that no digging or excavation  be undertaken beneath the Haram al-Sharif/Temple Mount compound  unilaterally or without express permission from both parties; 

c. Specifies that the political sovereignty of Haram al-Sharif/Temple Mount shall  be revisited in subsequent negotiations in five years; 

d. Pursuant to the the general principles outlined in UNSC Resolution 242 and 338,  demarcates the respective states’ sovereign borders in Jerusalem along the lines  attached in Annex A; 

e. Notes that Palestinian Jerusalemites with permanent residence status in Israel  shall lose this status if they reside in areas transferred to Palestinian sovereignty  pursuant to the interim agreement;  

f. Calls for an extension in zoning and planning areas designated for Palestinian  residential neighborhoods so as to encompass existing Palestinian homes in East  Jerusalem; 

i. Guarantees reforms to Jerusalem’s residential construction permit  application process to ensure equal access for Palestinian residents of  Jerusalem; 

ii. Allocates a greater proportion of humanitarian aid from Israel and the  United States to ensure that Palestinian neighborhoods in East Jerusalem  attain equal municipal standards for water quality, fire safety, and  infrastructural quality; 

g. Directs that the contents of an interim agreement be made available for public  viewing within six months of its signature, and, barring exceptions described in  the interim agreement, enter into force no later than three years after its first  public viewing;   

5. Article 5: Refugee Protocols 

a. Recognizes the hardship and displacement imposed on Arab civilians due to the  1948 Arab-Israeli War; 

b. Affirms, consistent with the positions articulated in the Clinton Parameters, that  displaced Palestinians shall be permitted to return to the State of Palestine with  ease,  

i. Emphasizes that an amount of 30,000-40,000 displaced Palestinians may  return to the State of Israel over a 10 year period; 

1. Notes that displaced Palestinians are specifically stateless (such  as those residing in Lebanon and Syria) and not those with  citizenship status in Jordan; 

ii. Directs that displaced Palestinians who wish to resettle in another  country shall be compensated; 

1. Establishes an International Commission with delegations from  both parties, the United States, and other parties invited to  provide oversight of resettlement, compensation, and integration  of returning refugees; 

iii. Notes that in the next round of negotiations that will occur in five years,  both parties will review their past operations for refugee resettlement in  order to see if UNGA Resolution 194 can be declared as completed;   

6. Hebron and the Mount of Olives 

a. Guarantees that peoples may exercise their right to access the religious sites in  Hebron and the Mount of Olives freely and without discrimination including but  not limited to race, religion, sex, gender/gender expression, sexual orientation,  physical ability, place of origin, age, and nationality; 

b. Notes that the JTF shall coordinate security at the Tomb of the Patriarchs and  Mount of Olives religious sites; 

c. Declares that said holy sites be maintained under Palestinian political  sovereignty, with joint religious custodianship over their access, maintenance,  and religious procedures; 

i. Establishes a Joint Custodianship Council (hereinafter the “Council”),  with religious representatives from the Parties, the United States, and the  Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan, to oversee religious decorum over the  sites; 

ii. Affirms the Council’s role as a steering body for the maintenance of free  access and security for the religious sites;   

7. Miscellaneous  

a. Reaffirms that the Parties are empowered to undertake further joint  proceedings to articulate the methods and modalities for cooperation; 

b. Establishes a follow-up negotiation that shall take place five years following the  passage of this Interim Agreement to do the following: 

i. Determine if UNGA Resolution 194 has been successfully implemented in  a manner satisfactory to both parties as per the terms of this agreement; 

ii. Review each parties’ compliance to this Interim Agreement in regards to  the status of Haram al-Sharif/Temple Mount in accordance to Article 4; 

iii. Review funding for programs established in this Interim Agreement; and  iv. Review the performance of the Joint Task Force in its structure and  purpose set forth in Article 1 and possibly make revisions which are  deemed necessary by all parties.